Logo
    Show
    Hide
    Login
    Close

    SITE LOGIN

    • Forgot your password?

    Register

    Tailgate Industries
    • REVIEWS
      • Ski Gear
        • Skis
        • Boots
        • Bindings
        • Climbing Skins
        • Poles
        • Snowboards
      • Clothing
        • Hard Shells
        • Soft Shells
        • Insulation
        • Mid Layers
        • Base Layers
        • Gloves
        • Socks
      • Accessories
        • Safety Gear
        • Goggles and Helmets
        • Ski Touring Packs
        • Ski Boxes and Bags
        • Sleeping Bags - 4 Season
        • Technology
        • Sunglasses
        • Insoles & Braces
        • Books
      • Off-Season Gear
        • Hiking
          • Rain Shells
          • Day Packs
          • Apparel
          • Footwear
          • Safety
        • Camping
          • Backpacks
          • Sleeping Bags
          • Sleeping Pads
          • Tents
          • Coolers / Cooking
          • Furniture / Storage
          • Lighting / Power
        • Biking
        • Paddling
        • Climbing
        • Mountaineering
        • Running
      • Lifestyle
      • Lodges and Accommodation
      • Nutrition
      • Manufacturers
      • Destinations
      • Training
      • Gear of the Year
        • Gear of the Year Winter 2024-2025
        • Gear of the Year Winter 2023-2024
        • Gear of the Year Archives
      • Best New Summer Gear
        • Best New Summer Gear 2023
        • Best New Summer Gear 2024
        • Best New Summer Gear 2022
        • Best New Summer Gear 2021
        • Best New Summer Gear 2020
      • Holiday Gift Guide
        • Holiday Gift Guide 2024
          • Holiday Gift Guide 2024 Base Layers
          • MSR Explore Revo Snowshoes
          • Fieldsheer Backcountry Heated Jacket
          • Fieldsheer Premium 2.0 Merino Heated Socks
          • MEC Hut Booties and Slippers
          • Arc’teryx Kopec GTX Shoe
          • Arc’teryx Kragg Insulated Approach Shoes
          • Gregory Verte 18 Backpack
          • Grundens Deck-Boss Ankle Boot
          • MEC Northern Light Vest
          • Montec-Scope-Ski-Goggles
          • Mountain Hardware Kor Airshell Hoody
          • Mountain Hardware Kor Alloy Crew
          • Arcade Atlas Belt
          • Dynafit Ridge Dynastretch Jacket
          • Shokz OpenRun Pro 2 headphones
          • Buff Merino Move Multifunctional Neckwear
          • Bootdoc Foot Warmer
          • Cotopaxi Allpa 42L Travel Pack
          • DPS LastBag
          • DPS PHANTOM Glide At-Home Kit
          • DPS Mission Quiver Roller
          • Dragon Amped sunglasses
          • Dragon DX3 Plus OTG photochromic goggle
          • Fuse Lenses Anclote Flashback
          • Garmin Fenix 8 Solar Sapphire Watch
          • Gregory Alpaca Gear Tote 30
          • Hotronic Boot Dryer
          • MEC Aluminum Pot Set
          • Gnara Go There Pants
          • Grundens Shackleton 2.0 Duffel
          • Jones Deeper 19L Backpack
          • Le Bent Core Midweight Crew base layer
          • Leatherman ARC
          • Montane Nordes Hooded Softshell Jacket and Pants
          • Helly Hansen Odin Everdown Hooded Jacket
          • Helly Hansen Verglas Infinity Shell Jacket 2.0
          • Montec Fawk Ski Jacket
          • Pomoca Free Pro 2.0 Skins
          • Rab Glaceon Pro Down Jacket
          • Rab Khroma Converge GORE-TEX Ski Jacket & Pants
          • Smith Squad MAG Goggles
          • Stellar Guide Aerogel Hybrid Hood 2.0
          • Stellar Ultralight Down Hood 2.0
          • Arms of Andes Alpaca Half Zip & Wool Leggings
          • Cotopaxi Allpa 70L Duffel Bag
          • Giro Taggert Mips Helmet
          • Loonr Hi Flyer Boots
          • Paka Mountain Crew
          • Roll Recovery SUPERPLUSH Classic Shoes
          • Smartwool Smartloft Hooded Jacket and Pants
          • Ortovox Switchback 32 Ski Touring Backpack
          • Cotopaxi Allpa X 3L Hip Pack
          • Giro Sagen Ski Goggle
          • Icebreaker Ski+ Over the Calf Socks
          • MEC-Fireside-Fleece-Snap-Pullover
          • Montec Roast Mittens
          • Mountain-Hardware-Sunblocker-Hoody
          • MSR Titan Kettle 900 ml
          • Tailgate-Industries-The Gondom-Goggle-Cover
          • Wild Country Rope Tarp
          • Bootdoc Race Merino PFI 50 Socks
          • Remind Soles Destin Impact Insoles
          • Kari Traa Rose Baselayer Half Zip Top and Pants
          • Le Bent Midweight Quarter Zip
          • Ombraz Dolomite Sunglasses
          • Ortovox Fleece Rib Hoody
          • Ortovox Merino Thermovent Base Layer
          • Smartwool Intraknit Merino Tech Half Zip
          • Suunto Wing Bone Conduction headphones
          • Sweet Protection Adapter Mips Helmet
          • Sweet Protection Connor Rig Reflect Goggles
          • Zeal Optics Selkirk Glacier Glasses
          • Norrona more flex1 Pants
          • Norrona Octa Zip Hood
          • Norrona Lyngen Alpha100 Zip Hood
          • MEC Deluxe Pillow
        • Holiday Gift Guide 2023
        • Holiday Gift Guide 2022
        • Holiday Gift Guide 2021
        • Holiday Gift Guide 2020
        • Holiday Gift Guide 2019
        • Holiday Gift Guide 2018
        • Holiday Gift Guide 2017
        • Holiday Gift Guide 2016
      • Pro Skier Interviews
    • NEWS
    • STORE
      • Guides & Maps
      • Gear Deals
        • Alpine Touring Boots
        • Backcountry Skis
        • Alpine Touring Bindings
        • Backcountry Accessories
        • Off-Season Gear
        • Climbing Skins
    • ROUTES
    • LODGING
      • Coast Mountains
      • Interior Mountains
      • Rocky Mountains
    • VIDEOS
      • 2022/23 Gear Reviews
      • 2021/22 Gear Reviews
      • 2020/21 Gear Reviews
      • 2019/20 Gear Reviews
      • 2018/19 Gear Reviews
      • 2017/18 Gear Reviews
      • 2016/17 Gear Reviews
      • 2015/16 Gear Reviews
      • 2014/15 Gear Reviews
      • 2013/14 Gear Reviews
      • 2012/13 Gear Reviews
      • 2011/12 Gear Reviews
      • 2020 Outdoor Retailer
      • 2019 Outdoor Retailer
      • 2018 Outdoor Retailer
      • 2017 Outdoor Presscamp
      • 2017 Outdoor Retailer
      • 2016 Outdoor Presscamp
      • 2016 Outdoor Retailer
      • 2015 SIA Show
      • 2014 Outdoor Retailer
      • 2013 SIA Show
      • 2012 Outdoor Retailer
      • Tips and Tricks
      • Backcountry Skiing
    • SAFETY
      • Plan Ahead
      • Equipment
      • Resources
      • Avalanche Skills Training
      • Managing warmth & heat loss
    • ABOUT
      • Advertise
      • Glossary
      • Contact Us
      • Newsletter
      • Contest
    • REVIEWS
      • Ski Gear
      • Clothing
      • Accessories
      • Off-Season Gear
      • Lifestyle
      • Lodges and Accommodation
      • Nutrition
      • Manufacturers
      • Destinations
      • Training
      • Gear of the Year
      • Best New Summer Gear
      • Holiday Gift Guide
      • Pro Skier Interviews
    • NEWS
    • STORE
      • Guides & Maps
      • Gear Deals
    • ROUTES
    • LODGING
      • Coast Mountains
      • Interior Mountains
      • Rocky Mountains
    • VIDEOS
      • 2022/23 Gear Reviews
      • 2021/22 Gear Reviews
      • 2020/21 Gear Reviews
      • 2019/20 Gear Reviews
      • 2018/19 Gear Reviews
      • 2017/18 Gear Reviews
      • 2016/17 Gear Reviews
      • 2015/16 Gear Reviews
      • 2014/15 Gear Reviews
      • 2013/14 Gear Reviews
      • 2012/13 Gear Reviews
      • 2011/12 Gear Reviews
      • 2020 Outdoor Retailer
      • 2019 Outdoor Retailer
      • 2018 Outdoor Retailer
      • 2017 Outdoor Presscamp
      • 2017 Outdoor Retailer
      • 2016 Outdoor Presscamp
      • 2016 Outdoor Retailer
      • 2015 SIA Show
      • 2014 Outdoor Retailer
      • 2013 SIA Show
      • 2012 Outdoor Retailer
      • Tips and Tricks
      • Backcountry Skiing
    • SAFETY
      • Plan Ahead
      • Equipment
      • Resources
      • Avalanche Skills Training
      • Managing warmth & heat loss
    • ABOUT
      • Advertise
      • Glossary
      • Contact Us
      • Newsletter
      • Contest
    Newsletter Signup

    TOP VIDEOS

      HOTTEST REVIEWS


      Hagan Boost 99 POW Skis Garmin inReach Plus Scarpa 4-Quattro Pro 130+ Top Ski Reviews Ortovox Ravine Jacket Scarpa Maestrale RS Boots

      Ortovox
      North Valley Huts
      Avalance Canada
      ROAM
      Fritschi Swiss Bindings
      Search
      • Home
      • »
      • Forum
      • »
      • Other talk
      • »
      • General Talk
      • »
      • Skier death on Youngs Peak at Rogers Pass - Accident Report

      BACKCOUNTRY NEWS AND FORUMS

      Welcome to your source for the latest news, conditions, and insights on backcountry skiing and adventuring. Explore reports, gear reviews, safety tips, and more to help you make the most of your time in the wild.

      If you sign up as a member this is your chance to tell everyone about everything and anything to do with backcountry skiing. Follow the simple steps to register and WHAMMY, you’re in. If you are pulling your hair out with frustration, have a look at the help forums for answers or take a pause and drop us an email at: info (at) backcountryskiingcanada.com. We’ll do our best to help out as soon as we can (but all bets are off on a powder day, obviously).  


      Skier death on Youngs Peak at Rogers Pass - Accident Report

      • RSS
      • Subscribe
      • admin
        2013-04-30 09:26:26

        Skier death on Youngs Peak at Rogers Pass - Accident Report

        A few weeks back it was reported on the site that a skier had died on Youngs Peak in Rogers Pass but there were few details know at that time. We have dug up the report filed by Parks Canada and it looks like the skier took a fall on a seldom skied line called "North Cirque Basin" just to the east of Forever Young Couloir. The complete Parks Canada report is below along with a photo outlining the events that took place. It's well worth a read to better understand what happened on April 22nd and how the skier died.


        While this is a tragedy and we feel for the surviving skiers in the group and the friends and family of the deceased I did want to start a dialog around this incident and the Parks Canada Analysis. We would like to hear your thoughts and how you feel about this incident.

        Do you think that this is a realistic line to ski depending upon skier ability and conditions?

        Do people really need to ski lines like North Cirque Basin and put themselves at risk (as well as those that have to potentially rescue them)?

        Does the risk off set the reward?

        If you ski lines like this do you consider the consequences?

        Could something like this be prevented from happening in the future?


        We don't mean to cause those involved any more heart ache by asking these questions but rather see if we can make some observations of our own and potentially learn from this tragedy. Thanks for your time.


        Here is the full report:

        Accident Report

        On April 22, 2013, a party of two skiers ascended Youngs Peak in the Asulkan area with the intent of skiing down the north cirque basin to the east of Forever Young Couloir. At approximately 12:30 pm, the first in the party skied 2/3 of the way down the slope and stopped on a spur. The second in the party then began his descent. On the fourth turn he hit something – possibly a rock – and began sliding down the steep slope. He was unable to self arrest and subsequently fell over a series of cliffs, coming to rest on a 30 degree slope below and sustaining injuries to the head and chest. 


        His partner skied down to him and performed initial first aid. Unable to get cell phone reception, he skied down until he met a group skiing up. Using their phone, he called 911 and initiated an emergency response. The group immediately skied to the accident site to assist with first aid.

         Youngs Peak Rogers Path backcountry skiing


        Red line: Victim's trajectory; 

        Blue line: Reporting Person’s line to “safe location” to spot;

        Green line: Reporting Person’s line to victim, and out valley bottom; 

        Red circle: Victim’s location after fall;

        Star: Helicopter landing spot;

        Arrow: "Forever Young Couloir” on Youngs Peak  


        Rescue Summary:

        At 12:56 pm, Jasper Dispatch called Parks Canada Visitor Safety Specialists in Rogers Pass B.C. and reported that an air ambulance from Kamloops was responding to a call for an injured and unconscious skier in Glacier National Park. Rescuers were able to speak directly to the reporting person and plan for a technical heli-sling rescue. A rescue helicopter was dispatched immediately, and within half an hour rescue personnel were on the scene of the accident. Within one hour of the initial report, the patient was assessed, packaged and transported to the waiting air ambulance. Sadly, the victim succumbed to his injuries.


        Analysis:

        Skiers and riders coming to Glacier National Park are beginning to branch away from standard ski lines to explore a more adventurous or challenging ski experience. This may be a response to “congestion” in popular ski destinations caused by the popularization of winter backcountry ski touring. Careful evaluation of committing terrain is required, as slips, avalanches and small sluffs can have serious consequences.


        Image and words from Parks Canada.

        http://www.pc.gc.ca/eng/pn-np/.....spx#youngs


      • 2wheeler
        2013-05-01 01:09:13

        I heard about this accident last week, and my condolences goes out to those affected.  


        Your list of questions is certainly provocative, maybe that was your intention? I'd like to address each one at a time.


        Do you think that this is a realistic line to ski depending upon skier ability and conditions?

        It is certainly a "realistic line to ski" .  People have been skiing much steeper and more complex lines for decades.  Yes, it depends on skier ability and conditions, but those decisions must be left up to the protagonist.   

        Do people really need to ski lines like North Cirque Basin and put themselves at risk (as well as those that have to potentially rescue them)?

        The answer here is simply yes.  I'm certain that most western ski hill resorts have areas that are just as steep and hazardous.  People should be able to do what they like in the backcountry and be free to make the decision regarding risk to themselves.  Your questions regarding endangering a potential rescue is a red herring.  If there is a continuing danger from objective hazards to search and rescue personnel then the operation shouldn't be carried out.  If it's a matter of the inherent risk of performing a rescue, well raising that question opens a whole new can of worms.


        If your question was framed differently such as "should backcountry skiing be allowed when there is the potential for SAR to be put in danger if a rescue is required" or "should hiking be allowed" etc. I'm certain you could answer your own question.  There are many more rescues each year of hikers and scramblers from the Rockies than backcountry skiers.  

        Does the risk off set the reward?

        A personal question that is different for everyone.  For Patrick Vallençant a slope like this would be a beginner run, for others 30 degrees is terrifying.  The same question could be asked of backcountry skiing in general, and hell, any activity where you're not wrapped in cotton wool in locked in the basement!  Does the risk offset the reward?  Overcoming the risk is the reward.


        If you ski lines like this do you consider the consequences or feel that falling and the possibility of death are not going to happen to you?


        I find this to be the most disturbing question because it seems to imply that skiing steeper terrain is more dangerous that other kinds of terrain.  Skiing is an inherently dangerous activity, sliding down slopes at speed you run the risk of something happening that you didn't calculate for.  Whether you're skiing in trees down Evening Ridge, hucking your meat into Delirium Dive, or carving turns down the green run groomer there is a chance that something will go wrong.  You may catch an edge, snag something under the surface of the snow, or hit some ice.  Accidents do happen, speed and obstacles create hazards for all skiers.


        To  take the question at face value and answer directly, I always consider the risk and consequences of a line and try to plan and ski appropriately.  However once you commit to ski it,  all of your mental and physical resources must be focused on success.


        How could something like this be prevented from happening in the future?


        Should we be doing something to prevent accidents like this from happening in the future?  Or should we embrace the attitude that life can be an adventure filled with risks and rewards and celebrate those who live that way? 



      • 2013-05-01 09:36:31

        The Line looks much worse then it is in reality. If it is only 30 degrees that is not that steep, your average black diamond run at a ski resort is about thsi steep in places. It sounds like this incident was purely bad luck and the skiers in the group were experiences and careful skiers from what I have heard. A tragedy.
      • TomD
        2013-05-02 14:49:34

        This is a very touchy yet important matter to have people think about and discuss. I feel terrible for those involved and it truly is an unfortunate tragedy. The questions raised are something that we should all be thinking about. Personally I always study incident reports and try to use some of that information in my future decision making process. I don’t believe that there can be clear-cut answers to those questions raised as the amount of risk and actual skier ability really depends on each individual. I do however want to say that many of us may be desensitized to the potential of injury by “extreme” skiing videos (I’m not implying that that is what happened here whatsoever). What I’m saying is that personally I’ve seen many videos where skiers/boarders have taken incredible spills and walked away fine. Is this something that plays on the minds of people out there getting after the big stuff?  I truly believe the vast majority of Backcountry users take the utmost precaution and always stay within their means. Having conversations such as this will potentially help the rest of us have that extra thought in our heads and aid in the decision making process. Again a true tragedy and my condolences to those involved.


        Tom D

      • skifreak
        2013-05-02 14:59:01

        TomD has raised a really good point.

        This is especially true of younger kids who know no different and are fueled by the prospect of filming a viral video for the Youtube crowd. It seems that now a days you are nothing unless you can do something that no one else does, i.e. extreme (insert sport here). The bottom line is that we are all human and we all make mistakes but the media does not help by only showing the successful attempts and not the mistakes. I have a young child and I am always talking to him about the risk of something and having the proper gear and knowledge to use that gear as well as the "what if's". Hopefully tragic accidents like this one can have a positive impact on others and we can all learn from them. So sorry to hear about this.


      Ortovox
      North Valley Huts
      Avalance Canada
      ROAM
      Fritschi Swiss Bindings
      • Terms of Use
      • Privacy Policy

      Copyright © 2023-24 Backcountry Skiing Canada. All Rights Reserved.