This would be much more useful if you post your height/weight/pant size(waist and length)/shirt and chest size and what size jacket and pants you tested.  I tried the jacket and really wanted to love it but the fit was off for me.  I'm 6'1″ and 175 with a 16″ sleeve.  The medium was too short in the sleeves.  The Large had sleeves that fit properly, but the chest was huge.  So huge that when I zipped the jacket up to the top, there was a big gap in th eneck opening that inevitably would have let in lots of snow and wind. I'm a big OR fan and have dozens of their pieces, but its frustrating the inconsistancy of sizing across the line and between model years.  Not a problem if you're able to try in on in the store, but it makes online ordering vauge at best.

On an unrelated note, I wish that comments were visible on the review page under the main posting.  The way it's set up now buries the comments so deep that their not as effective.

Hi Plinko, thanks for the feedback. I too have found OR's sizing to be a little sporadic. To give you some background on my sizing, I am 6'1" and 170lb with a 39.5" chest and 33" arms from the centre of the back. My pants size is 32"x32" but the OR Valhalla Pants did not fit as well as they could have, very loose and baggy looking but fit well in the length and hips so I think this is the loose cut style of the Valhalla. The pants are a medium and the jacket is a large. The jacket fit well but the shoulders were square cut and were a tad tight.

I am trying to get comments integrated into the reviews to make things easier but technology is a bit of a hurdle and it may have to wait until the next site upgrade. There is a link at the bottom of each review that takes you to the forum link such as this one where you can comment in the interim.

I hope that this helps you out and thanks again for the feedback.